46%

Fewer recalls than
Dairy peers

Butter Creek Farms — FDA Recall History & Enforcement Records

Established Player · Dairy

Data Notice: Recall frequency varies by category and firm size; data is comparative and may not indicate actual brand safety or quality. See Methodology.

As of July 16, 2026, Butter Creek Farms has 11 recorded FDA food enforcement actions in the openFDA database. Their most recent recall was on 31 Dec 2013. Butter Creek Farms is categorized under Dairy based on their predominant recall history.

11
Total FDA recalls
12.5
Years in FDA database
0.9
Recalls per year
4,580 days(12.5 yrs)
Since last recall
100.0%
Class I (life-threatening)
0.9 recalls/yr vs Dairy avg 2.4/yrWell Below Average

Recall activity over time for Butter Creek Farms

How serious are Butter Creek Farms recalls?

FDA recall classifications by severity

Class I (Life-threatening)
100.0% (11 recalls)
Class II (Moderate risk)
0.0% (0 recalls)
Class III (Minor violation)
0.0% (0 recalls)

Full FDA recall history for Butter Creek Farms

All 11 FDA enforcement actions sourced from openFDA · Sorted by date, most recent first

Date Product Reason Class & Status
31 Dec 2013Official FDA Notice Snickerdoodle Cookies Butter Creek Farms, Inc. is recalling Snickerdoodle Cookies due to undeclared Wheat and Egg. The firm sold single product or combined this product wi Class ITerminated
31 Dec 2013Official FDA Notice M&M Cookies Butter Creek Farms, Inc. is recalling M&M Cookies due to undeclared Wheat, Egg, Milk, and Soy. The firm sold single product or combined this product Class ITerminated
31 Dec 2013Official FDA Notice Double Chocolate Amaretto Cookies Butter Creek Farms, Inc. is recalling Double Chocolate Amaretto Cookies due to undeclared Wheat, Soy, Egg. The firm sold single product or combined th Class ITerminated
31 Dec 2013Official FDA Notice White Chocolate Macadamia Cookie Butter Creek Farms, Inc is recalling White Chocolate Macadamia Cookie due to undeclared Macadamia nut, Egg, Wheat, Soy, and Milk. The firm sold single Class ITerminated
31 Dec 2013Official FDA Notice Mock Baby Ruth Cookies Butter Creek Farms, Inc. is recalling Mock Baby Ruth Cookies due to undeclared peanut, egg, wheat, soy, wheat, and milk. The firm sold single product Class ITerminated
31 Dec 2013Official FDA Notice Peanut Butter Cookies Butter Creek Farms, Inc. is recalling peanut butter cookies due to undeclared peanut, wheat, soy, egg. The firm sold single product or combined this p Class ITerminated
31 Dec 2013Official FDA Notice Cow Chip, Calf Chip and Bull Chip are Chocolate Chip Cookies Butter Creek Farms, Inc. is recalling Chocolate Chip Cookies (Cow Chip, Calf Chip and Bull Chip) due to undeclared Wheat, Soy, Egg, Milk (butter is li Class ITerminated
31 Dec 2013Official FDA Notice Nutty Cow Chips, Nutty Calf Chips, and Nutty Bull Chips cookies Butter Creek Farms, Inc is recalling Nutty Cow Chip Cookies due to undeclared Walnut, Egg, Wheat, Soy, and Milk (butter was listed). The firm sold si Class ITerminated
31 Dec 2013Official FDA Notice Oatmeal Raisin Cookies Butter Creek Farms, Inc. is recalling Oatmeal Raisin Cookies due to undeclared Wheat and Egg. The firm sold single product or combined this product Class ITerminated
31 Dec 2013Official FDA Notice Sprinkle Cookies Butter Creek Farms, Inc. is recalling Sprinkle Cookies due to undeclared Wheat, Egg and Soy. The firm sold single product or combined this product wi Class ITerminated
31 Dec 2013Official FDA Notice Lemon Sugar Cookies Butter Creek Farms, Inc. is recalling Lemon Sugar Cookies due to undeclared Wheat and Egg. The firm sold single product or combined this product with Class ITerminated

Where have Butter Creek Farms recalls occurred?

States affected across all recorded FDA enforcement actions

IN, WA

Where does this recall data come from?

Verification required: FoodRecallFinder.com cannot verify the safety of individual food products in your possession. Always verify the current recall status at FDA.gov before disposing of or consuming a product.

Data sourced from the FDA Recall Enterprise System via openFDA API. This information is for educational purposes only and does not constitute health or legal advice. FoodRecallFinder.com is not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.

To determine if your specific product is affected, verify that the brand name, product description, lot number, UPC code, and date range all match the recall details exactly. When in doubt contact the recalling firm or visit FDA.gov.

© 2026 FoodRecallFinder.com | Turnkey Trading Unlimited LLC. All rights reserved. FDA recall data sourced from openFDA.gov.

How we calculate these metrics →